EveryPlate Vs Dinnerly Comparison

Do you ever feel bad about not cooking for yourself more often? Maybe you go out to eat, grab fast food on the way home, order takeout, or simply toss a packaged meal into the microwave. You don't have to feel guilty - that's the reality for many Americans. Meal planning and prep can get overwhelming, especially if you work a full week.

Meal delivery kits are systems that aim to take some of the challenge out of cooking. Rather than needing to find a recipe and shop for your ingredients, the ingredients and recipe are delivered straight to your door.

Different kits are structured in different ways. Some have gourmet recipes. Others have different skill levels and resources to teach you how to cook. Still others are built with convenience in mind, bringing you fresh meals when you're too busy to do all the steps yourself.

EveryPlate and Dinnerly are two budget-based meal delivery kits. They have some of the lowest per-portion pricing in the industry. Every week, you can choose from a selection of different options. The menus change from week to week, ensuring you always have some variety.

Though both services are very similar in terms of plans, pricing, and delivery structure, they do have a few differences. I've taken a look at both to help you decide which you'd prefer.

Overview of EveryPlate and Dinnerly

Shared Features

  • Meal delivery kits.
  • Similar pricing for shipping and meals.
  • Two available delivery plans.
  • First plan: three meals provided weekly to two people.
  • Second: three meals provided weekly to four people.
  • Different available meals every week.
  • Meals generally prepared in under 30 minutes.
  • Generous portion sizes.
  • Proteins packed in ice to stay fresh.
  • Easy online account management with support available.

Unique EveryPlate Features

  • Classic meal options with five unique choices every week.
  • Option to upgrade to meals including seafood or steak for a fee.
  • Recipe card included with every meal.
  • Ingredient card gives information about each included ingredient.

Unique Dinnerly Features

  • Six meal options that change on a weekly basis.
  • Easy options for families and vegetarians.
  • More affordable for feeding large groups.

Meal Style and Variety


EveryPlate provides five changing options every week for you to choose from. This is a fairly limited menu. By not making a large menu available, the service cuts down on the costs incurred by having too many ingredients on hand at one time.

EveryPlate vs Dinnerly

The goal of an EveryPlate recipe is to give you a classic meal that can be prepared without needing a lot of cookware. You may need basic cooking tools like pans or knives, but the system is optimized for those who don't have a kitchen outfitted with a ton of cooking elements.

You can also upgrade to premium meals. With premium meals, each portion costs an extra dollar. These recipes include more expensive ingredients, most commonly steak or seafood. This can be a good option if you want to feel like you have a luxurious home-cooked meal.


Though Dinnerly has a limited meal selection to cut down on prices, it still has a large list of options. Every week, there are six new options to pick from. You get a good deal of variety regardless of which plan you choose.

EveryPlate vs Dinnerly

One of the big selling points is that you can specify when you sign up that you want your boxes to be vegetarian. This means that you'll be given options with vegetarian proteins. For vegetarians, a drawback of budget meal kits is often that there are limited vegetarian options, so this is a huge plus for those with dietary limitations.

There are also child-friendly and low-carb recipes put onto the menu each week, though you don't have the option to have all of your meal options follow these guidelines. Still, the child-friendly recipes are great for people with kids who don't like more complex meals.

Most meals can be prepared in less than 30 minutes, making this the ideal option for those who don't have a lot of time or patience for cooking.

Winner: Dinnerly

For such inexpensive meal kits, both of these systems have easily-prepared meals with a surprising variety of options. The EveryPlate premium upgrade is a great feature. But Dinnerly comes out ahead because of the way that you can choose to have all of your meals be vegetarian, a choice that's great for people with dietary restrictions.

Popular Dishes

The menus change from week to week, so there's no telling exactly what you'll get. The recipes do sometimes repeat. These are some of the most popular items that are sometimes available.


  • Crisped pork chops with ranch seasoning and a roasted broccoli side.
  • Buttered herb steak with cheesy potatoes and roasted Brussels sprouts.
  • Scallion rice, zesty carrots, and chicken glazed with sweet chili.


  • Large bean burrito casserole recipe using cheddar cheese.
  • Seared chicken on a bed of buttered peas with a side of scalloped potatoes.
  • No-stir shrimp risotto with lemon seasoning and spinach.

Winner: EveryPlate

EveryPlate wins because the recipes tend to have a wider variety of cooking techniques applied. In addition, the portions are more like entrees you'd get at a restaurant rather than home-baked meals. But Dinnerly sometimes has seafood options without needing to upgrade, and the meals don't require a lot of cooking knowledge to prepare.

Interface Ease of Use


EveryPlate vs Dinnerly

Registering for EveryPlate is straightforward and simple. All account elements can be managed online. You can pre-select menus, make changes prior to delivery, update your contact and payment info, and view your past orders.

EveryPlate has foods for common diets. The meals include pork, poultry, and other meat. One premium and vegetarian meal are offered every week.


EveryPlate vs Dinnerly

Registering for the service is very straightforward. You can change your meal plan and skip weeks if need be. You can order meals, change meal selections, update contact and payment details, and access your past orders.

One helpful feature is that you can view future menus in advance. This means getting to see all of the nutritional facts, ingredients, and recipes before they're available.

Dinnerly's meal plans all have special markings to designate when a meal meets characteristics like:

  • No additional gluten.
  • Dairy-free.
  • Low carb.
  • Low calorie.
  • Vegetarian.
  • Kid-friendly.
  • Under 30 minute cook time.

Winner: Dinnerly

Dinnerly's menu has more clearly marked options for different dietary needs. In addition, the ability to look at future menus in advance is a huge help for those who like advance planning.

See Full Review of - EveryPlate | Dinnerly

Pros and Cons of EveryPlate


  • There tend to be classic menu options that have a good balance of proteins, carbs, and nutrients.
  • The preparation process doesn't tend to require any complicated techniques.
  • You have the choice to upgrade your meal options to include more expensive ingredients for a small fee.


  • You only have five options to choose from per week, so if you don't like them, you're out of luck.

Pros and Cons of Dinnerly


  • There are six different options for meals every week, giving you slightly more choice.
  • Typically, the program will include vegetarian options each week.
  • There are also options to get meal plans and portions to serve families rather than just one or two people.


  • There's no option to upgrade the cost or quality of your ingredients, so you're unlikely to have meals including seafood or steak.

Final Thoughts: Which Is Better?

Both of these meal kit delivery services provide low-cost meals with similar packaging and meal variety. The pricing per portion is about the same, and the structuring of the plans is similar as well. That means that the right one for you depends mostly on which kinds of foods you prefer.

EveryPlate works best for those who want the option to have more expensive ingredients. For an additional one dollar per person per month, you can get menu options that have seafood and steak. These may make you feel a little more luxurious. The meals all tend to follow classic recipe structures.

Dinnerly is best if you want the most available meal options per week. Every week, you have six new meals to choose from. There are also more readily available vegetarian options every week, and the pricing may be more flexible for those who have larger families to feed.


Official Top 5 Review Team
Official Top 5 Review Team

The Official Top 5 Review team is dedicated to testing and researching the top products available for many different industries. We do the research and testing so that you don't have to! We welcome you to provide your feedback on your experiences with any products that you have experience with.

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply

Official Top 5 Review