Top Baseball Glove Recommendations

If you're looking for a new baseball glove, it can be a bit intimidating with all the different styles and options available. It can be especially challenging to separate the high quality products from basic models.

The most important factor to consider when purchasing a baseball mitt is comfort. The material of the glove should also be durable and made with high quality materials. In order to play at the highest performance level, an optimized level of comfort, functionality, and durability has to be achieved.

The products that are listed in this countdown have checked off all of these important aspects. Here are the top five baseball gloves that you should be looking at.

Top 5: Baseball Gloves Review

Rawlings Player Preferred Baseball Glove, Regular, Slow Pitch Pattern, Basket-Web, 12-1/2 Inch

The number one product on this countdown is the Rawlings Player Preferred Regular Baseball Glove. This glove is extremely popular in the baseball industry and has received hundreds of positive reviews to prove it. It has also received a #1 Best Seller rating on Amazon.

The Player Preferred is tuned to fit adult-sized hands and for those who play in slow-pitch and recreational softball and baseball leagues. 

This glove is 12.5 inches long, with an added Zero Shock palm pad for extra protection. Although some of the reviews reported that this glove was more stiff then normal, its professional design makes this glove extremely simple to break in and use immediately after purchase.

Rawlings Player Preferred Baseball Glove, Regular, Slow Pitch Pattern, Basket-Web, 12-1/2 Inch
Rawlings Player Preferred Baseball Glove, Regular, Slow Pitch Pattern, Basket-Web, 12-1/2 Inch

This glove comes with a conventional back Flex Loop Strap, so getting your hand in and out of the glove is easy. Additionally, a basket web ensures that you will feel secure catching the ball at any angle. This glove is very comfortable so you can focus out on the field.

This product is perfect for left and right handed players and is also suitable for nearly any baseball position, including first base. The conventional catching design ensures that a good amount of forgiveness is always there - no stinging palms!

It has earned its #1 Best Seller rating for a variety of reasons, but the most important reason is because it provides a sufficient level of quality while retaining an affordable price range.


  • #1 Best Seller on Amazon.
  • High quality design.
  • Extremely durable.


  • Stiff feeling.
Franklin Sports Baseball and Softball Glove - Field Master - Baseball and Softball Mitt - Adult and Youth Glove - Right Hand Throw - 13"

The number two product on this countdown happens to be the Franklin Sports Field Master Series — Left-Handed or Right-Handed Softball & Baseball Glove. This glove is all about providing great value. It is by far the cheapest option on this entire list and it still features exceptional features for the price.

The tan glove design makes for a noticeable and traditional design that could be appealing for older players. There are several sizes to select from and the glove is available for players that are left and right handed.

Franklin Sports Baseball and Softball Glove - Field Master - Baseball and Softball Mitt - Adult and Youth Glove - Right Hand Throw - 13"
Franklin Sports Baseball and Softball Glove - Field Master - Baseball and Softball Mitt - Adult and Youth Glove - Right Hand Throw - 13"

This glove offers several amazing features to take notice of. In addition to being a durable glove, Franklin constructed this model to have a thicker synthetic leather. This construction provides the suppleness of a leather glove without the need to break one in. And, since it isn't leather, you can adjust the glove for your fit. The Contour Fit System provides customizable thumb adjustments.

As an affordable option, and one that comes in many sizes, this glove is the perfect fit for your game.


  • Affordable price range.
  • Several size options available.


  • Short term durability.
Franklin Sports Pro Flex Hybrid Series Baseball Fielding Glove, Right Hand Throw, 12-Inch, Black/Camel

Just because this glove is lower in price range, doesn't mean that it lacks important features related to quality.

This Franklin Sports Pro Flex Hybrid Series Baseball Glove features premium durability and an adjustable wrist strap for added comfort. There are five glove sizes to choose from (11.5, 12, 12.5, 13, 13.5 inches) and the glove is available for left handed players as well as right handed.

Franklin Sports Pro Flex Hybrid Series Baseball Fielding Glove, Right Hand Throw, 12-Inch, Black/Camel
Franklin Sports Pro Flex Hybrid Series Baseball Fielding Glove, Right Hand Throw, 12-Inch, Black/Camel

The cowhide palm inside was upgraded to include a PU-laminated PVC hybrid shell, so you won't hurt your hands as often. This glove also comes with an adjustable wrist strap for added versatility.

The glove comes from a reputable sports brand with an impressive track record. Customer reviews are extremely positive and there is no doubt that this one is capable of providing customers with a sufficient level of quality out on the baseball field.


  • Extremely affordable price range.
  • Five glove sizes to choose from.
  • Adjustable wrist strap.


  • General durability.
Mizuno GPP1150Y1 Youth Prospect Ball Glove, 11.5-Inch, Right Hand Throw

This Mizuno GPP1150Y1 Baseball Glove has earned the number four spot on this list because it is extremely high quality and has received immensely positive reviews.

This mitt is designed by Mizuno specifically for youth players, both left and right handed.This glove is designed with a patented PowerClose, which provides catching forgiveness. The design is intended to help improve youth players to make catches in the pocket of the glove.

Some other added features include Heel Flex Technology, for increased flexibility and closure, V-Flex Notch for easy closure and PowerLock, for a quick fit. The high durability design is one of the final touches that makes this glove so impressive.


  • Affordable price range.
  • Right and left handed designs.
  • Ideal for youth players.


  • Limited size options.
  • Not ideal for professional players.
Wilson A700 11.5" Baseball Glove - Right Hand Throw

The number five selection is the Wilson A700 Baseball Glove Series, an affordable option that doesn't restrain or limit itself to low quality just because of the price.

With pro laced T-Web, you will never let another ball drop. There are four different sizes to choose from and designs for both right and left handed catchers. The glove is constructed with full grain leather and provides a comfortable feeling for baseball players that are ready to participate in a competitive baseball atmosphere.

Wilson A700 11.5" Baseball Glove - Right Hand Throw
Wilson A700 11.5" Baseball Glove - Right Hand Throw


  • Left and right handed orientation.
  • Full grain leather quality.
  • Reputable sports brand.


  • High end price range.
  • General durability.

best baseball glove - Buying Guide

All of the baseball gloves on this list are extremely impressive, and it's important to consider how each could benefit your play. You might be looking for a particular style or feeling which can make the search a little bit more nuanced.

There are obviously a lot of different factors to consider when making any sports equipment purchase, but the most important thing to consider is whether the product will be satisfactory for your needs. These gloves are all designed to provide players with a certain level of quality and comfort. The challenge is finding the right balance so that you are at your best performance.

Frequently Asked Questions

This section is designated to provide customers with the answers to commonly asked questions about baseball gloves. There are important things to consider before committing to a purchase, and some of these questions could potentially answer important topics relating to your purchase.

Are All Baseball Gloves Designed the Same Way?

The answer to this question is no, mainly because different glove manufacturers focus on providing a specific level of comfort to their customers. Some gloves are a little bit looser when attached to your hand, while some manufacturers create a tighter and stiffer glove that wraps itself around your hand. There is no right or wrong design, but certain players will have their own preference.

Price or Comfort? Which Is More Important?

If you are a casual player and are just learning the basics of baseball, you might want to invest in a cheaper mitt to start off. As you continue to gain experience and get more comfortable, then you might want to begin searching for a glove that fits your play style and preferences.

Professional players that compete at a high level should certainly focus on comfort as well as functionality. It is definitely worth paying a higher price so that you can be comfortable and at your optimal performance when out on the field.

How Can You Be Sure That Your Baseball Glove Will Be Durable?

Obviously players don't want their baseball mitts tearing apart or getting worn out over time. Higher quality gloves will usually last a lot longer than the cheaper ones. So purchasing a higher quality glove might be a bigger investment up front, but you won't have to break in a new glove every season. It's important to go with a reputable baseball brand if you are looking for enhanced durability.

Final Verdict

Now is a great time to begin closing in on the baseball glove that you really want to purchase. Each of these options will be a great addition to your upcoming baseball season.


The Official Top 5 Review team is dedicated to testing and researching the top products available for many different industries. We do the research and testing so that you don't have to! We welcome you to provide your feedback on your experiences with any products that you have experience with.

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

      Leave a reply

      Official Top 5 Review