The Best Recommendations For Ice Cream Makers

Are you looking for a way to make cool and refreshing treats at home? Do you and the other members of your household love ice cream? If so, an ice cream maker may be the perfect addition to your kitchen.

An ice cream maker allows you to make fresh and delicious ice cream in your own home. There are many different styles that offer different functions, so it can be challenging to decide which model is right for you. This is why we have reviewed five of the best ice cream makers to assist you in finding the best ice cream maker for you.

Top 5: Ice Cream Makers Review

Nostalgia ICMP400WD Electric Wood Bucket Ice Cream Maker, 4-Quart

The Nostalgia ICMP400WD is a product that is designed to look like an old hand-churn model. While it looks like an old hand-churn maker, this product is electric, so you won't need to wear out your arm muscles to enjoy your ice cream. This product can make up to four quarts, or one gallon, of ice cream at a time.

In addition to using this product to make ice cream, it can also be used to make frozen yogurt and gelato. A see-through lid is also included with your purchase. This will allow you to store it directly in the bucket and be able to see exactly what is left.

Additionally, there is a motor lock that secures the electric motor in place. This helps to make sure that none of the components of the product are damaged once the churning is in motion. When you purchase this item, you'll also receive recipes in the product manual. You can create or find your own fun recipes to try with this product.


  • Can make large batches at a time.
  • See through lid for easy vieing.
  • Can make gelato and frozen yogurt, too.


  • The motor may need a few adjustments to work properly.
Cuisinart ICE-100 Compressor Ice Cream and Gelato Maker, Silver, 1-1/2-Quart

The Cuisinart ICE-100 is an automatic ice cream maker. The compressor in this product is commercial-quality, and it can make up to one-and-a-half quarts at a time. This product comes with two paddles. One paddle is designed to make gelato, and the other paddle is designed to make ice cream. A recipe book with delicious ice cream and gelato recipes is included with your purchase.

To use this product, all you need to do is add your ingredients and start the machine. There is a countdown timer, touchpad controls, and a blue LCD display to help you keep track of how much more time is needed to complete your ice cream. After the timer goes off, the unit will keep it cool for 10 minutes to allow you time to get it in the freezer.

Since this product has a commercial compressor, you will be able to start one batch right after another batch is finished. This product features a transparent lid to allow you to watch it being made. There is also an opening in the lid that will allow you to conveniently add some of your favorite treats to be mixed into the ice cream while the machine is going.

The inner mixing bowl features a handle to make it easy to lift out of the machine. The bowl is made from anodized aluminum, which means that you won't need to freeze the bowl before making the ice cream.


  • There are separate paddles for gelato and ice cream.
  • This is a fully automatic machine, for easy creations.
  • Designed with commercial compressor to make multiple batches in a row.


  • Some people who have used this product have noted that it is difficult to thoroughly clean the unit after making ice cream.
Whynter ICM-201SB 2.1 Quart Upright Stainless Steel Bowl  Ice Cream Maker

The Whynter ICM-201SB is an automatic ice cream maker with over two quarts of capacity. You can use this product to make ice cream, gelato, or sorbet. This product features a stainless-steel bowl, ideal for getting your ice cream cold quickly. The churn blade is BPA free and is removable, so it is easy to clean.

This product has an attractive stainless design and a small footprint. This means it will look great on your countertop without taking up too much space. It also has an LCD control panel with a time to ensure you get perfect batch every time.

The compressor in this unit is high-efficiency, so you'll be able to make multiple batches. This product also has a motor protection function. It will automatically shut off to prevent damage to the unit in the event the ice cream become solid.


  • Uses stainless-steel bowl to quickly cool the ingredients.
  • This product has a small footprint.
  • Designed with high-efficiency compressor.


  • This is one of the more expensive products we reviewed.
Yonanas 902 Classic Original Healthy Dessert Fruit Soft Serve Maker Creates Fast Easy Delicious Dairy Free Vegan Alternatives to Ice Cream Frozen, Silver

If you prefer soft serve ice cream, then you should consider the Yonanas 902 Classic Original Healthy Dessert Maker. With this product, you can churn fruits and create an ice cream-like result.

The treats you'll make with this product will be much healthier than those you'll make with a true ice cream maker. You can even make 100% fruit desserts with this product. Or, if you'd prefer, you can add chocolate into the mix to create an extra special treat for yourself to enjoy.

Using this product is quick and easy. You just need frozen fruit, then all you need to do is insert your fruit into the chute and push the plunger down. Clean-up is simple with this product. The plunger, chute, and blade can all be placed in the dishwasher.


  • The components of this product are dishwasher safe.
  • You can use this product to make healthier desserts.
  • All you need to make your sweet treat is some frozen fruit.


  • This isn't a true ice cream maker; it just makes a fruity treat with a consistency that is similar to ice cream.
Breville BCI600XL Smart Scoop Ice Cream Maker

The Breville BCI600XL Smart Scoop is an automatic ice cream maker with a one-and-a-half-quart capacity. This product offers many added features that most other options don't have.

To allow you to make a variety of frozen treats, such as ice cream, sorbet, frozen yogurt, or gelato, this product has 12 different hardness settings you can select from. It has a keep cool function that can keep your freshly made ice cream cool for up to three hours.

This product has a child lock to prevent little hands from interrupting the ice cream-making process. Once yours is finished, you will hear an alert. You can choose from three different musical alert options, so it will sound like your personal ice cream man is pulling up to your home.

There is a pre-cool button on the console for this product. It allows you to get the machine cooler to make it more quickly. The instruction manual for this product offers you various recipes for delicious ice cream concoctions that you're sure to love. You can enjoy it right away or store it in the freezer for up to one week.


  • There are 12 hardness settings on this machine which will allow you to make treats such as ice cream, gelato, frozen yogurt, or sorbet.
  • You can choose from different musical sounds or alert settings to notify you once it's finished.
  • This product has a pre-cool button. This will allow the machine to get cold before you begin to making.


  • Since this product has so many advanced features, its cost much more than most of the other options.

icecream maker Buying Guide

As you've probably realized by now, there are a lot of different options to consider when you are looking for an ice cream maker. When you are looking for a new ice cream maker, there are a few features you should pay attention to in order to decide which product is best for you.

One feature to consider is the capacity. Think about how many people you'll likely be making ice cream for and make sure you choose a product that will make enough to serve everyone.

Another feature you should consider is how easy it is to use. Do you just need to add your ingredients and press a few buttons, or will it be more involved to make ice cream?

Finally, you should also pay attention to whether the machine can create other frozen treats, such as gelato or frozen yogurt. If you think you'll enjoy making these other treats sometimes, then be sure to pick a product that can make more than just ice cream.

best icecream maker

We think all five of the products we reviewed are great ice cream makers. However, our top pick is the Whynter ICM-201SB 2.1 Quart Upright Stainless-Steel Bowl Ice Cream Maker.

The Whynter is our top pick for a few different reasons. We love that you are able to use this product to make gelato and sorbet in addition to ice cream.

We also like the overall design of this product. It has a stainless-steel finish that will look great in your kitchen. Additionally, it has a small footprint, so it won't steal all of your precious counter space.

Whynter ICM-201SB 2.1 Quart Upright Stainless Steel Bowl  Ice Cream Maker

The Whynter also has a stainless-steel bowl. Stainless steel is the ideal material to help cool the ingredients quickly to yield a delicious ice cream.

Finally, the compressor inside this unit is high-efficiency. This means that you'll be able to make multiple batches.

We think the Whynter would be a great addition to your kitchen. It will allow you, your friends, and your family to enjoy a cool, refreshing, and freshly made bowl of ice cream whenever you want.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do All Ice Cream Makers Require Rock Salt?

Typically, rock salt is best for making ice cream. Rock salt helps the ingredients to get colder and form ice cream more quickly. If you don't have rock salt, you can use table salt, it just might not be quite as effective.

How Much Does an Ice Cream Maker Cost?

There are different models that vary in price. You should expect to spend anywhere from less than a hundred dollars to a few hundred dollars on your new ice cream maker.

Why Does Ice Cream Need to Be Churned?

When ice cream is churned, it helps prevent ice crystals from connecting with one another. If they would connect with one another, it would lead to icier ice cream that would not be as smooth.

Is Homemade Ice Cream Cheaper?

The answer to this question will vary depending on the cost of the ingredients. To make your own at home, you'll need cream, sugar, and other ingredients that will vary depending on the type of ice cream you're planning to make.

Whether you would buy a gallon of ice cream at a grocery store or ice cream from a parlor as the alternative to making your own will also affect whether it will be cheaper for you to make your own.

Final Verdict

Now that you've read through our reviews, it is time for you to make your decision about which ice cream maker is best for you. Then, you can purchase your product so you can begin enjoying delicious homemade ice cream whenever you'd like!


Official Top 5 Review Team
Official Top 5 Review Team

The Official Top 5 Review team is dedicated to testing and researching the top products available for many different industries. We do the research and testing so that you don't have to! We welcome you to provide your feedback on your experiences with any products that you have experience with.

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply

Official Top 5 Review